Ranking the Best ICEE Flavors: User Favorites & Expert Picks

The Ultimate Guide to the Best ICEE Flavors

That moment of decision is pure summer magic: standing in front of the swirling, colorful icee machine near me, trying to pick between your favorite frozen flavors. Do you stick with a classic or take a chance on something new? You want that perfect brain-freezing, flavor-packed treat—but with so many choices, deciding can be tough. Don’t worry, this guide is here to help.

We’ve explored the frosty world of this iconic frozen drink to bring you the ultimate ranking of the best ICEE flavors. Whether you’re a long-time fan or just discovering your first ICEE, get ready to find out which flavors truly stand out and why they’ve become legends.

Our Ranking Methodology: How We Chose the Best

Choosing the best ICEE flavor isn’t as simple as it sounds. To make this list as fair and accurate as possible, we looked at several key factors:

• Sales Data & Popularity: We analyzed which flavors are ordered most often across the country.
• Social Media Sentiment: We checked which flavors get fans talking (and craving) the most on social platforms.
• Community Polls: We reviewed online fan surveys to see which flavors consistently rank high.
• Expert Taste-Testing: Our team sampled and rated each flavor for boldness, balance, and refreshment factor.

This balanced approach ensures our list reflects not just popularity, but true fan-favorite status.

Top 5 Most Popular ICEE Flavors (and Why They Stand Out)

After all the data and countless taste tests, five flavors rose above the rest. These are the ultimate ICEE staples—flavors that deliver nostalgia, fun, and unbeatable taste in every sip.

What are the best ICEE flavors ranked?

1. Cherry: The undisputed classic. The Cherry ICEE strikes the perfect balance of sweet and tangy, with that bright red hue that feels instantly familiar. It’s more than just a drink—it’s a memory in a cup. Simple, bold, and perfectly refreshing.

2. Blue Raspberry: The electric-blue superstar. Sweet, tart, and unlike any natural berry flavor, Blue Raspberry has that fun, artificial charm we can’t resist. It’s the perfect complement to Cherry and the go-to choice for anyone craving a vivid, candy-like kick.

3. Coca-Cola: A frozen twist on a soda classic. The Coca-Cola ICEE delivers that fizzy cola flavor with a refreshing, icy texture. It’s smooth, energizing, and perfectly balances sweetness with a touch of caffeine.

4. Lemonade: Zesty and crisp, the Lemonade ICEE brings a tangy punch that’s especially satisfying on a hot day. Not too sweet, not too sour—it’s the perfect thirst-quencher when you want something light and refreshing.

5. Watermelon: Sweet, juicy, and perfectly nostalgic. The Watermelon ICEE tastes just like summer in a cup—cool, smooth, and full of fruity goodness. It’s a seasonal favorite that always delivers.

Hidden Gems: Underrated ICEE Flavors Worth Trying

Beyond the big five, there’s a whole world of delicious ICEE flavors waiting to be discovered. If you’re feeling adventurous, try one of these underrated picks next time you visit an icee machine near me:

• White Cherry: A smoother, creamier twist on the original Cherry. It’s rich, sweet, and less tart—ideal for those who like a mellow flavor profile.
• Mango: A tropical delight bursting with authentic mango sweetness. Refreshing and exotic, it’s perfect for anyone craving a fruity getaway.
• Fanta Orange: Fizzy, citrusy, and fun. This one tastes just like your favorite orange soda, only colder and crunchier.

Community Favorites: What ICEE Fans Are Saying

Fans love to experiment, and social media is full of creative ICEE combos. The most famous mix? The Cherry–Blue Raspberry “Swirl,” sometimes called a “Suicide ICEE.” It blends the best of both worlds—sweet, tart, and visually stunning.

Longtime fans also reminisce about flavors that have disappeared, often hunting down a discontinued ICEE flavor from their childhood. It’s proof that ICEE isn’t just a drink—it’s a shared piece of nostalgia.

The Science Behind Flavor Preference

Ever wonder why you crave certain ICEE flavors more than others? It’s part science, part psychology. Bright, vibrant colors like red and blue signal sweetness and excitement to the brain, enhancing your enjoyment before you even take a sip. That’s why flavors like Cherry and Blue Raspberry remain unbeatable classics—our eyes love them as much as our taste buds do.

Whether you’re after something tangy, fruity, or fizzy, the next time you find an icee machine near me, you’ll know exactly which flavor to grab first. And who knows—you might just discover a new favorite.